State tests meet student resistance

Seniors statewide balk at taking lengthy new assessment

Posted 11/9/14

High school seniors throughout Colorado refused to participate Nov. 5 and 6 in a state-mandated test. Many school leaders, parents and students hope the expected low participation rate sends a clear message about what they believe is excessive …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Don't have an ID?

Print subscribers

If you're a print subscriber, but do not yet have an online account, click here to create one.


Click here to see your options for becoming a subscriber.

If you made a voluntary contribution of $25 or more in Nov. 2017-2018, but do not yet have an online account, click here to create one at no additional charge. VIP Digital Access Includes access to all websites

Our print publications are advertiser supported. For those wishing to access our content online, we have implemented a small charge so we may continue to provide our valued readers and community with unique, high quality local content. Thank you for supporting your local newspaper.

State tests meet student resistance

Seniors statewide balk at taking lengthy new assessment


High school seniors throughout Colorado refused to participate Nov. 5 and 6 in a state-mandated test. Many school leaders, parents and students hope the expected low participation rate sends a clear message about what they believe is excessive standardized testing.

“People don't always listen to educators, but they do listen to parents and students,” Cherry Creek School District spokeswoman Tustin Amole said. “This may be very helpful in letting policy makers know how parents and students feel.”

A state education official said the student response likely will result in significant discussion.

The first week in November was the beginning of three weeks of state-issued social studies and science tests for high school seniors called the Colorado Measures of Academic Success.

Colorado students in fourth, fifth, seventh and eighth grades underwent CMAS testing in spring 2014.

The online test is a partial replacement for both the original Colorado Student Assessment Program, administered until 2011, and the Transitional Colorado Assessment Program, issued in 2012 and 2013. Those exams were designed to test third- through 10th-grade students' math, science, reading and writing skills.

A separate CMAS test, the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College & Career, will test third- through 11-grade students in reading writing and math beginning in spring 2015.

Seniors added to testing schedule

CMAS adds social studies to the list of subjects and comes with another twist: It added seniors to the list of those expected to take the six-hour test.

Castle View High School senior Rachel Decker is among hundreds who didn't take the CMAS assessment at her Castle Rock school. As an outgoing student, Decker said the test won't benefit her academically and has no bearing on her future plans.

“My parents were in full agreement with me,” she said. “I know only about 50 students who actually took the test, and some of them just made up answers or drew pictures in the (test) bubbles.”

The decision to add testing at the 12-grade level was in part because the exams are designed to test knowledge acquired throughout high school, said Joyce Zurkowski, the Colorado Department of Education's director of assessment, and to allow schools control over when in the four-year high school schedule to offer the instruction.

But she said state officials knew scheduling a standardized test for seniors was a gamble.

“We knew we were approaching a line with the fall of 12th grade,” Zurkowski said, but added the options appeared limited. “I don't think (the students' response) was completely unanticipated. In the long run, I don't know that it will stay at fall of 12 grade.”

In the future, Zurkowski said state assessments may be made more meaningful, perhaps by linking them to higher education or post-high school work places.

“Long term, will kids have to take both the ACT and PARCC in Colorado?” she said. “I don't know.”

Logistical challenges in DougCo

Student investment in taking the tests isn't the only issue.

Both the number of computers and the length required for CMAS testing presented high schools in Douglas County with challenges. Castle View, Rock Canyon, Chaparral and Douglas County high schools gave underclassmen two half-days Nov. 5 and 6 to accommodate the testing. Schedule changes also were expected Nov. 12 and 13 during testing at Highland Ranch, Mountain Vista and ThunderRidge high schools. Make-up test dates also were designated.

Despite the accommodation, many Douglas County School District seniors either let school leaders know they were opting out of the Nov. 5 and 6 tests, or didn't show up for them.

Several DCSD principals contacted about students opting out of CMAS testing did not return calls to Colorado Community Media, and the district referred questions on CMAS to state education officials.

Several Castle View parents, students and teachers said well over 50 percent of the high school's students did not attend the sessions. Some seniors at the other DCSD schools that scheduled tests for Nov. 5 and 6 also opted not to participate.

Shared concerns

Testing is set for Nov. 13 and 14 at high schools in Cherry Creek and Boulder Valley, where leaders said student unrest is clear.

“There's been quite a bit of conversation about students opting out,” Boulder Valley Superintendent Bruce Messinger said. “I've met with students. They've communicated with me. I'm not upset with the students. These are very high-performing students — these aren't students who are motivated to skip school. Most of them will be in college (when results come back).

“If it were of great benefit to them individually or to our school district, we might take a stronger stance. I'm not going to force the students to take a test.”

At Cherry Creek, Amole said the district is requesting only that parents notify the school of the absence if a student chooses not to take the test. Amole said student discussions reflect those of parents and other adults concerned about excessive testing.

“We need to respect our kids,” she said. “They are adults, or nearly adults, and need to make choices for themselves about what they think is the best thing for them to do.”

Impacts for schools

Colorado Department of Education officials said they need 95 percent of students at each school to participate in the test to ensure they have accurate data, a figure set by federal legislation. The data helps education leaders make state, district and school-level policy decisions, according to the CDE.

Without that participation rate, a school's performance framework rating could drop one level. The state's performance framework includes four levels, ranking a school's academic achievement and postsecondary readiness, among other factors.

Schools are not impacted financially by test participation percentages.

Districts can, however, file a request for reconsideration if a school's rating changes. They must then provide evidence to the state of a good-faith effort to test all students.

The state already knows that at least some students are taking the tests. As of 10:30 a.m. on Nov. 6 — with two more weeks of testing to go — Zurkowski said seniors had completed 25,000 assessments. If every student took the test, the CDE would receive 110,000 assessments, she said.

Messinger said Boulder Valley will make a good-faith effort to administer the test. He's optimistic the student response could prompt change.

“Our hope is over time our state board of education and Legislature will listen to this input, and maybe consider a better balance,” he said. “We aren't saying there isn't any need for assessment. This just seems like way too much for us.”


2 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment

Thank you for documenting this ridiculous mandate to test seniors who have already been administered standardized tests since 3rd grade (now kindergarten using PARCC). These students are in the midst of ACTs, SATs and college applications. That is where their focus should remain. When will the administrators and politicians realize that our students are so much more than what is identified in a single test score tied to meaningless memorization and data mining of our students?

A couple of points of clarification. Castle View had less than 25% of its students take the CMAS test last week. The logistical challenges go beyond what was detailed here. CVHS had 12o teachers proctoring a test taken by 110 students. That is less than a 1:1 teacher to student ratio, at the same time class sizes exceed 30-35 students per teacher on a regular basis. Why would the district or state value proctoring a standardized test over the actual education of our students?

Even with the schools keeping all other students out of school to allow for access to computers and bandwidth to take the test, CVHS experienced significant technical difficulties. In this "world class district", our schools do not have sufficient computers or bandwidth to administer the test to less than 25% of seniors and slightly over 5% of the CVHS student population. Some of the "gutless computers" that schools were encouraged to purchase because of a lack of proper funding for technology in our schools, did not even work and are anticipated to not be functional for the PARCC test during which 75% of our students will be tested in the spring. Further loading and taking the CMAS test was painfully slow and even halted at times because there was insufficient internet access (bandwidth) to accommodate 110 computers in a school that normally houses almost 2,000 students. How can a district claim to be "world class" when the students do not have access to the tools they need to learn in the "21st century" environment of DCSD on a daily basis?

Once again, DCSD has misled the public. The tens of millions of dollars that have gone to technology costs have been used to pay subcontractors and cronies to build bureaucratic administrative systems and to equip the administrators and the Wilcox building (central office) with the latest and greatest technology. The district website looks so fancy and "world class", but on any given day our students do not have the computers or bandwidth to access that website, let alone the learning resources needed in today's educational environment.

The CMAS test for seniors is meaningless and wasteful, but the DCSD lack of support for its schools and students, amidst propaganda about all the great things happening in DCSD, is the REAL STORY here. What you see and hear in the DCSD glossy magazines and advertisements paid for with public funds simply are not true - THE REFORMS ARE FAILING OUR STUDENTS!

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

Exactly what Julie Keim said. Perfectly stated and an accurate assessment of our Douglas County School District.

Thursday, November 13, 2014